The private ledger
A payment between two Counterseal accounts is an entry in the Counterseal Private Ledger and is not published to any public chain. This is the “+ 1” in Blockchain² + 1.
Payments the public cannot see.
On a public chain, anyone can read who paid whom, how much and when, forever. A payment between two Counterseal accounts is an entry in the Counterseal Private Ledger. It is never published to a public chain. This is the kind of shielding that Railgun made familiar on Ethereum, offered for assets from any supported chain, Bitcoin included.
| Privacy systems on public chains (Railgun, Zcash) | Counterseal Private Ledger | |
|---|---|---|
| How privacy is achieved | Every payment is published in encrypted form, with a zero-knowledge proof (a zero-knowledge proof: a short piece of data that lets anyone check that a statement is true without learning anything else) that it is valid. | The payment is not published at all. Only deposits and withdrawals touch a public chain. |
| Work on your device | Your phone or PC computes a heavy zero-knowledge proof for each payment. Most hardware wallets cannot do it. | No zero-knowledge proof to compute. Your device shows the payment and takes your confirmation. |
| Cost per payment | A public-chain transaction fee every time. | No public-chain fee for payments inside the private ledger. |
| Chains | Each system works on its own chain or chain family. | One private ledger for assets from many chains, Bitcoin included. |
What we do and do not claim. "Private" here means private from the public. In the first release, the private ledger's own open-source code reads balances and payment details in order to check them. Stricter levels follow in later releases: first the Shielded level, in which balances and history can be read only inside your own Counterseal Token (below), and then a level with the same reach as Railgun's privacy.
Records only your device can read.
At the Shielded level, planned for Release 3.0, the private ledger keeps your balances and history in a form it cannot read.
What stops stolen funds from entering.
Funds entering the private ledger must come with a zero-knowledge proof that they do not originate from addresses on public lists of thefts and sanctioned sources.
The proof is produced on the owner's side and reveals nothing else about the owner's history. No company examines or identifies depositors.